A good mascara earns its place by matching your lash goal while staying put through the day. The wrong formula can leave you with flakes, smudges, or clumps before lunchtime.
This comparison brings together the best rimmel mascaras across lengthening, curling, volumizing, waterproof, and conditioning styles. Keep reading to see which specifications matter most for your routine.
Key Takeaways
- Choose a lengthening formula if definition matters more to you than dramatic volume.
- Prioritize a waterproof finish for humid weather, long days, or tear-prone eyes.
- Check the brush design because curved, tapered, and oversized wands create different lash effects.
- Select extreme black for stronger contrast, or a softer shade for a more natural look.
- Compare the tube size and pack count if you wear mascara frequently or want a backup.
| Everyday Lash Staple |  |
Rimmel Extra Super Lash Black | Classic black shade | Simple daily option | Familiar mascara format | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Waterproof Volume Defender |  |
Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Black | Waterproof formula | Smudge-proof wear | Extreme Black shade | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Length-Focused Pick |  |
Rimmel Lash Accelerator Extreme Black | Length-focused design | Extreme Black shade | Easy daily styling | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Compact Classic |  |
Rimmel Extra Super Lash Black | Classic black shade | Compact listed size | Simple daily format | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Curl And Plump Specialist |  |
Rimmel Scandaleyes Curve Alert Black | Curl-focused design | Volumizing claim | Plumping effect | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Retro Volume Builder |  |
Rimmel Scandaleyes Retro Glam Black | Volumizing formula claim | Plumping lash effect | No-clumps positioning | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Clean Length Enhancer |  |
Rimmel Wonder'Extension Extreme Black | Lengthening focus | No-clumps claim | Smudge-proof positioning | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Longwear Volume Choice |  |
Rimmel Wonder'Luxe Volume Black | Volume-focused formula | Long-wearing claim | Smudge-proof positioning | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Dimensional Lash Definition |  |
Rimmel Extra 3D Extreme Black | Dimensional look focus | Extreme Black shade | Compact listed size | View on Amazon | Read Review |
| Lightweight Waterproof Wear |  |
Rimmel Wonder'Lash Waterproof Black | Waterproof formula | Lightweight feel | Conditioning claim | View on Amazon | Read Review |
More Details on Our Top Picks
-
Rimmel Extra Super Lash Black
For a straightforward daily mascara, this is a sensible starting point. The black shade gives your lashes a classic look, while the simple Extra Super Lash name points to an uncomplicated makeup-bag essential.
You will appreciate its easy everyday role if you prefer a familiar mascara rather than a highly specialized formula. The limitation is that the available listing provides few detailed claims, so you should not expect a clearly defined waterproof, lengthening, or volumizing benefit.
- Brand:Rimmel
- Product Type:Mascara
- Shade:Black
- Key Claim:Extra lash effect
- Additional Feature:Designed for everyday lash makeup
- Additional Feature:Classic black color
- Additional Feature:Straightforward mascara format
-
Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Black
Choose this version when staying power matters most. Its waterproof formula and smudge-proof claim make it a strong fit for humid weather, long days, and occasions when you want less concern about transfer.
The Extreme Black shade creates a more dramatic appearance than a softer brown or black-brown option. The trade-off is typical of waterproof mascara: removal may require more effort, especially if you prefer a quick cleanser-only routine.
- Brand:Rimmel
- Product Type:Mascara
- Shade:003 Extreme Black
- Size:0.41 oz
- Key Claim:Waterproof, long-wearing
- Additional Feature:Designed for extended wear
- Additional Feature:Helps resist smudging
- Additional Feature:Bold black color
-
Rimmel Lash Accelerator Extreme Black
The name makes this the clearest choice for a length-focused look. If you want your lashes to appear more elongated without prioritizing a heavily thickened finish, Lash Accelerator is the most targeted option in this group.
Its Extreme Black shade adds definition at the lash line and can make the lengthening effect look more pronounced. Since the listing does not specify waterproofing or wear time, you should treat those areas as unconfirmed limitations.
- Brand:Rimmel
- Product Type:Mascara
- Shade:Extreme Black
- Key Claim:Lash acceleration
- Additional Feature:Emphasizes lash length
- Additional Feature:Rich black color
- Additional Feature:Single mascara format
-
Rimmel Extra Super Lash Black
This is another version of Rimmel’s Extra Super Lash, suited to shoppers who want a classic black mascara in a clearly listed 0.27-fluid-ounce size. Its uncomplicated positioning works well for a basic daily routine.
You get a familiar, no-frills option rather than a formula built around a specific waterproof or curl claim. The limitation is the lack of detailed product information, so features such as smudge resistance and lash separation cannot be confirmed from the listing.
- Brand:Rimmel
- Product Type:Mascara
- Shade:Black
- Size:0.27 fl oz
- Key Claim:Extra lash effect
- Additional Feature:Suitable for everyday makeup
- Additional Feature:Traditional black color
- Additional Feature:Straightforward lash styling
-
Rimmel Scandaleyes Curve Alert Black
Curve Alert is aimed at you if curl and lift matter as much as color. The product name specifically highlights volumizing and plumping, giving it a more shape-focused profile than Rimmel’s basic Extra Super Lash options.
It makes sense for lashes that look flatter or need a fuller outline. The limitation is that the listing does not state waterproof or smudge-proof performance, so you may want a separate long-wear option for humid conditions.
- Brand:Rimmel
- Product Type:Mascara
- Shade:001 Black
- Size:0.41 oz
- Key Claim:Volumizes and curls
- Additional Feature:Designed to enhance curves
- Additional Feature:Plumps the lash appearance
- Additional Feature:Black lash definition
-
Rimmel Scandaleyes Retro Glam Black
Retro Glam is built around a fuller, more dramatic lash look. Its volumizing and plumping claims suit you if you prefer visible definition over a barely-there finish.
The no-clumps positioning is especially useful for anyone who wants separated-looking volume rather than heavy, spidery buildup. Because the available listing does not confirm waterproofing or wear duration, its performance may be less suited to very long days or wet weather.
- Brand:Rimmel
- Product Type:Mascara
- Shade:003 Extreme Black
- Size:0.4 oz
- Key Claim:Volume without clumps
- Additional Feature:Retro-inspired lash styling
- Additional Feature:Designed to plump lashes
- Additional Feature:Extreme Black color
-
Rimmel Wonder'Extension Extreme Black
Wonder'Extension is the natural pick for a longer-looking lash effect with a cleaner finish. The no-clumps claim should appeal to you if you want definition without sacrificing a tidy, separated appearance.
Its smudge-proof positioning adds practical value for workdays and regular wear, while the Extreme Black shade keeps the result bold. The key limitation is that the listing emphasizes length rather than volume, so it may not satisfy you if maximum fullness is the priority.
- Brand:Rimmel
- Product Type:Mascara
- Shade:003 Extreme Black
- Size:0.37 oz
- Key Claim:Lengthens lashes
- Additional Feature:Designed for extension-like length
- Additional Feature:Helps resist smudging
- Additional Feature:Bold black finish
-
Rimmel Wonder'Luxe Volume Black
Pick Wonder'Luxe Volume when you want fuller-looking lashes backed by a long-wearing formula. Its smudge-proof positioning makes it a practical option for office hours, evenings, and other situations where your makeup needs to hold its shape.
The Extreme Black shade supports a more intense eye look, while the volume-first design gives it a stronger presence than a length-only mascara. The limitation is that the listing does not promise curl or waterproof performance, so those needs remain outside its stated focus.
- Brand:Rimmel
- Product Type:Mascara
- Shade:003 Extreme Black
- Size:0.37 fl oz
- Key Claim:Long-wearing volume
- Additional Feature:Designed to build volume
- Additional Feature:Helps resist smudging
- Additional Feature:Intense black color
-
Rimmel Extra 3D Extreme Black
Extra 3D is the better fit for you if you want lashes with a more dimensional appearance rather than a single-focus length or curl effect. The 003 Extreme Black shade adds strong contrast and helps frame the eyes.
Its 3D naming suggests a multidimensional lash look, but the listing does not provide specific claims for volume, wear time, or clump control. That limited detail is the main drawback if you need a mascara matched to a precise performance goal.
- Brand:Rimmel
- Product Type:Mascara
- Shade:003 Extreme Black
- Size:0.27 oz
- Key Claim:3D lash effect
- Additional Feature:Creates multidimensional styling
- Additional Feature:Defines lashes in black
- Additional Feature:Designed for eye definition
-
Rimmel Wonder'Lash Waterproof Black
Wonder'Lash combines waterproof wear with a lightweight feel, making it a strong match for you if traditional waterproof mascaras often feel heavy. The conditioning claim also gives this formula a more comfort-oriented profile than a purely dramatic option.
Its Extreme Black shade provides definition, while the waterproof design suits wet weather and extended wear. The trade-off is the small 0.2-ounce size, and waterproof formulas generally take more care to remove than non-waterproof mascaras.
- Brand:Rimmel
- Product Type:Mascara
- Shade:003 Extreme Black
- Size:0.2 oz
- Key Claim:Waterproof, conditioning
- Additional Feature:Designed for lightweight wear
- Additional Feature:Helps resist moisture
- Additional Feature:Extreme Black color
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Rimmel mascara is best for volume?
Look for a Rimmel formula marketed for maximum volume or a false-lash effect, usually paired with a large, densely bristled wand. These mascaras are designed to deposit more product, creating a fuller appearance in fewer coats. Apply from the roots and wiggle the brush upward, but avoid repeated passes after the formula begins to set. For a softer result, wipe excess mascara from the wand before applying.
Does Rimmel make waterproof mascara?
Yes, Rimmel offers waterproof versions in several mascara ranges, although availability can vary by shade, retailer, and country. Check the tube or product listing for a clear waterproof label rather than assuming a long-wear claim means water resistance. Waterproof mascara can be useful for humidity and tears, but it usually needs an oil-based remover. Remove it gently at night instead of rubbing the lashes dry.
Is Rimmel mascara suitable for sensitive eyes?
Some people with sensitive eyes use Rimmel mascara comfortably, but suitability depends on the individual formula and your own sensitivities. Check the ingredient list, avoid sharing, and choose a product with a simple formula if your eyes react easily. Stop using it if you notice redness, itching, or stinging. If irritation continues after removal, consult a healthcare professional.
How many coats of Rimmel mascara should you apply?
Start with one thin coat, allowing it to distribute evenly from root to tip. Add a second coat while the first is still slightly workable if you want more volume or length. More coats do not always create a better result. If lashes become heavy or clumpy, comb through them with a clean lash comb and use less product on the next application.
How long does Rimmel mascara last after opening?
Replace mascara about every three months, even if some product remains. The tube is repeatedly exposed to air and bacteria, especially when you pump the wand in and out. Replace it sooner if the formula develops a strange odor, dries out, or causes irritation. Keep the tube tightly closed and do not add water or remover to extend its life.
